Tragedy at Daylite Inn: Elkhart Community Mourns the Loss of Allen Cogswell, 35
Elkhart, IN – June 24, 2025 — Grief and disbelief grip the Elkhart community in the wake of a deadly shooting that claimed the life of Allen Cogswell, 35, in the early hours of Sunday, June 22. The incident occurred at the Daylite Inn, located on Cassopolis Street, where authorities responded to reports of gunfire shortly before 1:00 a.m.
Upon arrival, officers from the Elkhart Police Department discovered Cogswell inside one of the motel rooms, suffering from multiple gunshot wounds. Emergency responders attempted life-saving measures, but tragically, Cogswell was pronounced dead at the scene. His sudden and violent death has sent shockwaves through the community and left his family, friends, and neighbors devastated.
According to police, the investigation is still in its early stages. Detectives spent much of Sunday morning canvassing the scene, collecting forensic evidence, and interviewing potential witnesses. No suspects have been publicly identified at this time, and authorities have not released information regarding a possible motive. The incident has been classified as a homicide, and investigators are urging anyone with knowledge of the shooting to come forward.
Allen Cogswell was more than just the victim of a tragic act — he was a beloved son, a caring friend, and a respected member of the Elkhart community. Those who knew him describe him as soft-spoken, kind-hearted, and someone who always tried to help others, even when he himself was facing challenges. While his life wasn’t without its difficulties, Allen was said to be on a path toward rebuilding and bettering his future. His death has left many reflecting on the fragility of life and the senselessness of violence.
“This is a tremendous loss,” said one longtime friend. “Allen had a heart of gold. He made mistakes like anyone else, but he was working hard to turn things around. It’s heartbreaking that his life was taken before he had the chance to fully show the world who he was becoming.”
The Daylite Inn, where the incident occurred, has been the focus of law enforcement attention in the past, with residents raising concerns over its safety and management. Sunday’s tragedy has renewed calls for greater oversight of high-risk locations and sparked conversations about crime prevention, mental health support, and substance abuse services in Elkhart.
Local leaders and community organizations have extended their condolences to Cogswell’s family and have pledged to support the ongoing investigation. A memorial vigil is being organized for later this week to honor Allen’s life and call for justice.
In a public statement, the Elkhart Police Department expressed its deepest sympathies to the family and emphasized its commitment to solving the case:
“We understand the pain that this tragedy has caused. Our detectives are working diligently to follow every lead and bring accountability to those responsible for Mr. Cogswell’s death. We urge anyone with information to come forward — even the smallest detail could be crucial.”
Anyone with information about the incident is encouraged to contact the Elkhart Police Department at (574) 295-7070, or provide anonymous tips via Michiana Crime Stoppers at 1-800-342-STOP (7867).
As the investigation continues and the community awaits answers, the memory of Allen Cogswell lives on in the hearts of those who loved him. His life, though tragically cut short, will not be forgotten — and the call for justice grows louder with each passing day.
